In chapter 6, “Broken Windows” and the Meanings of Disorder, Sampson argues that
social disorder as well as physical markers of disorder affect a neighborhood’s
negative reputation long after the original causes for such reputation are
gone. Such social and physical disorder also may provide environmental cues,
which encourage potential predators and eventually, illegal activity. According
to Sampson, “disorder theory itself may be self-fulfilling by triggering
attributions and predictions in the minds of insiders and outsiders alike.” Sampson
elaborates that elements of disorder compromise highly visible cues to which
neighborhood observers differentially respond under certain social conditions,
potentially influencing migration patterns, investment by businesses,
reputation of places; thus, overall neighborhood viability.
The U.S. Department of Justice’ article, Preventing Neighborhood Crime: Geography
Matters, by Ronald E. Wilson and Timothy H. Brown, http://www.nij.gov/journals/263/neighborhood-crime.htm, refers to neighborhoods as geographical
frames of reference, encompassing the demographic, economic and ecologic
characteristics of a particular place. This article too states that areas with
high rates of crime and deviant behavior tend to be physically deteriorated
places and in addition, residences are often mixed with less-than-desirable
commercial establishments.
Outsiders may be alerted not enter certain
neighborhoods that "look bad." This also applies to how businesses
view neighborhoods; fear of possible victimization and potential loss of
investment may affect their decision to invest or to do business such areas.
Whoever said, “Don’t judge a book by its cover,” did not think of “hoods.”
Yes, research has shown that blighted and deteriorated
neighborhoods are associated with crime. As a major in Integrated Studies with
emphasis in Business and Recreation Management, I plan to control the physical
deterioration in a neighborhood; consequently, influence potential offenders’
perception of such area's vulnerability to crime, as well as influence
residents' and visitors alike fear of crime. And yes again, fear of crime
though, based on visual cues alone, is not always substantiated. And, disorder
may invite criminal activity, but no, it does not cause crime.
I liked your blog. It helped me understand better what was being talked about in the chapter. I am guilty of looking at an area that looks physically unattractive and use that as my judgement that it's not an area for me. I didn't think about how that same unattractiveness could attract crime or potential offenders because they felt there were other people there with the same "low" standards or moral. At least that's what I understood it to be. I liked your comment of how you will apply your recreational management emphasis to this blight in neighborhoods. A lot of food for thought. Good job.
ReplyDeleteThat is an excellent observation about business not wanting to invest in areas they perceive to be bad. I believe that when private sector investment decides to leave or decides against investing in certain areas; the inner cities decline even further. It is already difficult for many in urban areas to find access to many of the resources we take for granted, like supermarkets, variety stores, and other such businesses. Great post...
ReplyDeleteI find that when the problem is more than we can handle, then we shut down and ignore the possibilities. I believe that is what broken windows is all about - when people shut down and no longer believe in the possibilities - both those within the hood and those without. The possibilities are there, and so are the resources, the help and the understanding needed to make those possibilities a reality.
ReplyDeleteI would like to see what we could do, as a community of students, to change the possibilities right here in St. George. There's a lot of people willing to help, and things already started. We could just help. That would be a curious thing to me. :)